the cutting room mirror

Part 1

This article has a talk page!
view on tcrf.net

This is a sub-page of Proto:Phantasy Star IV: The End of the Millennium.

Intro#

May 30

Aug 15

Final

The long long war from ancient
times was finally over.

The winner sacrificed
the loser to the heavens.

Four bells tolled.
Four torches were lit.

And the world continued
for thousands of years...

The long, long war of ancient
times had finally ended.

The Victor sacrificed
the vanquished to the heavens.

Four bells tolled.
Four torches were lit.

And the world continued
for a thousands years...

The long, long struggle of
ancient times finally ended...

The victor sacrificed
the vanquished to the heavens.

Four bells tolled.
Four torches were lit.

And the world continued
for thousands of years...

Translation Notes
It looks like the August script tried to change the text to "a thousand years" but forgot to change "thousands." Thousands is correct anyway, which is why that change was reverted in the final script.

May 30

Aug 15

Final

The Algo solar system,
bearing its existence
in the heavenly skies
...
In the past, within those
stars in the system,

a brilliant civilization
flourished.
The people devoted themselves
completely
to the pursuit of prosperity
and pleasure
.

But,
in
a series of disasters
the planet's management system,
'Mother Brain,' was destroyed.
The result was the destruction
of
the first planet 'Parma'
and
over 90% of the
entire population.
The advanced scientific
civilization
was lost
and the lives of the people
declined into poverty.

A thousand years has passed...

In time a renewed
strength and determination
emerged among
the people to try to make
propsperity take root again.
Due to cruel circumstances
that would not be
allowed to happen quite
that easily...

The Algo solar system,
somewhere in space...

Once a brilliant civilization
flourished here.
The citizens devoted themselves
to art and the sciences,
and life was prosperous
and good
.

Then a series of disasters
struck.
The system-wide management
system, 'Mother Brain,' was
destroyed.
So was the first planet, Parma.
Over 90% of the system's
population died, and the
advanced technological culture
was lost.

Society
declined then,
spiralling downward until
at last only a few scattered
groups even remembered there
had once been better times
.

A thousand years have passed.

At last, civilization in once
more on the rise across the Algo
system.
People are again turning to
thoughts of an easier life.
Old knowledge is being
rediscovered.

But just as things look
brighter, beyond a threshold
long thought closed, a dark and
very ancient evil stirs...

The Algo solar system,
somewhere in space...

Once a brilliant civilization
flourished here.
The citizens devoted themselves
to art and the sciences,
and life was prosperous
and good.

Then a series of disasters
struck.
The system-wide management
system, 'Mother Brain,' was
destroyed.
So was the first planet, Parma.
Over 90% of the system's
population died, and the
advanced technological culture
was lost.

Society declined,
spiralling downward until
at last only a few scattered
groups even remembered there
once were better times.

A thousand years have passed.

At last, civilization is once
more on the rise across the Algo
system.
People are again turning to
thoughts of an easier life.
Old knowledge is being
rediscovered.

But just as things look
brighter, beyond a threshold
long thought closed, a dark and
very ancient evil stirs...

Translation Notes
The line "and over 90% of the" in the May script doesn't actually show up in-game due to a misplaced control code.

All translations have pretty much the same content until halfway in, when the August script just starts making stuff up. The parts about old technology being rediscovered and the ancient evil aren't in the May prototype or the original script. Those additions turn this scroll from a prologue to a preview of what's to come later in the game.

In the May prototype, the screen fades out as soon as the last line of text leaves the top of the screen. The timing was never changed to accommodate the newer, longer block of text that the August and final scripts have. Now the screen fades out when the line "rediscovered." leaves the top of the screen, leaving less time to read the last four lines.

Aiedo#

In grand JRPG tradition, this story opens with an older authority figure (Alys) shouting at the main character (Chaz).

May & August Scripts

Hey, this is your first job
since you've registered
as a hunter
.

You'd better put your heart
into it!

Final Script

This is your first job since
you joined the Hunters Guild.
You'd better put your heart
into it!


May & August Scripts

I see,
I'm not a trainee anymore.

Final Script

So... I'm not a trainee anymore.

May & August Scripts

From this day on, you are a full-fledged partner!
We're off!

Final Script

From this day on, you are a full-fledged partner!
Now come on! Let's go!

May & August Scripts

Well,
where are we off to this time?

Final Script

Where are we off to this time?

It's a bit far.
We're going to Motavia Academy
in the town of Piata.

May & August Scripts

Wow! So we're going to
the town of learning!
I wonder what's happened there?

Final Script

Wow! So we're going to
the Town of Learning!
I wonder what's happened there?

May & August Scripts

Who knows? The message
said 'Just come.'
We'll have to get the details
once we're there.

Final Script

Who knows? The message said
'Just come.'
We'll get the details
once we're there.

Motavia Overworld#

Chaz and Alys head towards the east.

May & August Scripts

Since we're going there,
I'd sure like to see
the sights of
the Academy.

Final Script

Since we're going to be there
anyway, I'd sure like to tour
the Academy.

May & August Scripts

How can you even think
such a thing?
I'll leave you behind
if you don't get moving!

Final Script

Is that all you can think about?

Get moving or I'll leave you
behind!

May 30

Aug 15

AW 2884 The frequent outbreak of
monsters and those people called
hunters who have been called
upon to tackle this matter. ---- This was just an ordinary scene
for the planet Motavia.

Yes, even now...

AW 2884. Monsters attacks
have swelled the ranks of
those
who call themselves 'Hunters.'
But as the attacks become ever ---- more frequent and powerful, an
elite few begin to wonder what
is behind this outbreak... and
when and how will it all end?

Translation Notes
The editor(s) rewrote the entire opening text from scratch. Most of the content is the same, but the part about wondering what caused the outbreak and how it would all end only appears in the final English script.

The May draft is split nicely into two different chunks, with the second chunk appearing after the first fades off the screen. The later English text isn't as nicely split, with the first chunk fading in the middle of a sentence.

Piata#

May & August Scripts

Oops? I wandered around and now
I've gotten separated from Alys.
I've got to find Alys...

Final Script

Oops! I wandered around and now
I've gotten separated from Alys.
I've got to find her...

After walking about 10 steps to the west, Chaz is reunited with Alys.

May Script

Chaz, I've found you!

What are you doing,
bumming around?

Final Script

Chaz, where have you been?
C'mon, let's go!



Translation Notes
The first line is more accurately translated as, "Chaz, I've been looking for you!" Since Chaz finds Alys, not the other way around, the line in the May draft doesn't make sense.

May Script

Alys!

Final Script

But...

May Script

C'mon, follow me! We got to
see the principal and get
details about this commission.

Final Script

We have to see the principal
and get the details about this
commission.

In the principal's office... PhantasyStarIVCutscenePrincipal1.png

May Script

Wel...welcome.
I'm the principal of this
academy.
Let's see, you must be Alys,
the hunter,
and you are her assistant, Chaz.

Final Script

Welcome.
I'm the principal of this
academy.
Let's see, you must be Alys,
the hunter,
and you are her assistant, Chaz.

Translation Notes
The principal is more audibly nervous in the Japanese and May prototype scripts.

May Script

Forgive me, but Chaz is an
important,
full-fledged partner
of mine.

Anyway,
let's get down to brass tacks.
Describe the situation.

Final Script

Forgive me, but Chaz is a
full-fledged partner of mine.
Now, let's get down to business.

Describe the situation.


Translation Notes
A bit strange that they swapped one idiom for another here. Maybe the thought brass tacks was too obscure?

May Script

OK. It...it's like this.
About a month ago...

Final Script

Ah...

Translation Notes
The final draft formats the Principal's explanation differently, with the line about monsters coming immediately after the monster picture shows up on-screen.

May Script

Mysterious monsters started to
appear within this academy!
It appears that they have made
the basement their headquarters.
I've since closed it off.
So far we've been without
incident, but who knows when
they'll appear again?
Please I beg you to destroy
them all!
I'd like to settle this
matter discrectly,
I'm counting on your talent and
reputation, Alys.

August Script

About a month ago mysterious
monsters started to
appear within this academy!
It appears that they have made
the basement their headquarters.
I've since closed it off.
So far we've been without
incident
, but who knows when
they'll appear again?
Please destroy all those
creatures.

Ah...I'd like to settle this
matter discreetly,
I'm counting on your
reputation, Alys.

Final Script

About a month ago...
Mysterious monsters started to
appear within this academy!
It appears that they have made
the basement their headquarters.
I've since closed it off.
So far no one's been hurt, but
who knows when they'll appear
again?
Please, I beg you to destroy all
those creatures!
Ah...I'd like to settle this
matter discreetly,
I'm counting on your
reputation, Alys.

Translation Notes
"Been without incident" was rewritten to the more grave "no one's been hurt". Strangely, the Principal begging for help was deleted from the August draft, then put back in the final script.

May Script

No problem. You can rely on me.
Although,
it's strange that they suddenly
appeared in this academy.
Usually monsters don't come into
town areas.
Do you have any idea
how this happened?

Final Script

No problem. You can rely on us.
Although, it's strange that all
those monsters
suddenly
appeared in this academy.
Usually monsters don't come into
inhabited areas.
Do you have any idea
how this happened?

May Script

Of...of course,
I don't have any idea.

Stop asking questions,
just hurry and exterminate
those monsters!
After all, I'm paying you dearly
for your services!

Final Script

How would I know?

Stop asking questions.
Just hurry and exterminate
those monsters!
Don't forget, I'm paying you
dearly for your services!

Translation Notes
More stammering from the Principal here. It's more apparent that there's something suspicious about him in the early draft.

Chaz and Alys walk out of the principal's office.

May Script

Something smells fishy here.
That principal is just too edgy.


Final Script

Something smells fishy here.

That principal was hiding
something
.

Translation Notes
He's not really on edge in later drafts, so that line had to be rewritten.

Maybe he's afraid
of the monsters?

May Script

I don't think that's
the whole story
.
Things are getting
a little
interesting!

Final Script

I think there's more to it than
that
.
Things are starting to get
interesting!

At the basement's entrance, a nervous man in a white shirts paces back and forth.

May & August Scripts

What? You're the hunter?
Really?

Final Script

What? You're the hunters?
Really?

Translation Notes
Hahn and Alys both leave Chaz completely out of this conversation in the May and August prototypes.

May Script

You mean you don't trust me?

August Script

You mean... you don't trust me?

Final Script

You don't think we can do the
job
?

May Script

No, no, not at all!
Really, that's not true!

Final Script

No, no, not at all!
I didn't mean that!

May & August Scripts

Since I have the principal's
permission, let me pass.

Final Script

Since we have the principal's
permission, let us pass.

Wait!
Take me with you!

May Script

...Hmm. Seems like there's
a story behind this.

Final Script

Hmm. And why should we?

May Script

I am an assistant at this
academy and
my name is Hahn.
Actually, a professor named
Holt, whom I looked up to as
my mentor,

has gone to investigate
Birth Valley for his research.
We haven't heard from him since.
So, Now I am searching for
the professor's whereabouts!

Final Script

My name is Hahn.
I am an assistant at this
academy.

I work for professor Holt,
who has gone to investigate
Birth Valley for his research.
We haven't heard from him since.
So, now I am searching for
the professor's whereabouts!

Translation Notes
Hahn went from just looking up to Professor Holt to working for him in later drafts.

May Script

Birth Valley...
that's the mysterious valley
that has been called
the sacred precincts of life.

Final Script

Birth Valley...
that's the mysterious place
that has been called
the sacred valley of life.

Translation Notes
The editor(s) wanted to space out the two uses of "valley" here.

But what's the connection
between the valley and this
current monster scare?

May Script

After the investigation team
led by the professor was
reported missing, the principal
barred everyone from entering
Birth Valley!
We're trying to get information
as to what's going on, but
he keeps evading the issue.
And then a month later this
monster scare begins!
I'll bet anything that
there is some sort of connection
between these incidents.

Final Script

After the investigation team,
led by the professor, was
reported missing, the principal
barred everyone from entering
Birth Valley!
We're trying to get information
as to what's going on, but
he keeps evading the issue.
And then this monster scare
begins!
I'll bet anything that
there is some sort of connection
between these incidents.

Translation Notes
The later drafts delete Hahn's reference to the Birth Valley incident happening a month prior. This is mentioned later anyway, so it's not a big loss.

May Script

Hmm, well it is true that
there is something fishy
about the principal's actions.

Final Script

Well it's true that
there is something fishy
about the principal's behavior.

May Script

Given the circumstances,
I feel compelled to investigate
the basement myself.
But come to think of it, it is
kind of scary... ha ha ha!

Final Script

Given the circumstances,
I feel compelled to investigate
the basement myself.
But come to think of it,
it is a bit dangerous...

Translation Notes
Hahn occasionally laughs out of nervousness in the May prototype and the Japanese script. This character trait was pretty much eliminated in later English drafts.

May Script

So you were just waiting
for me to arrive?

Final Script

So you were just waiting
for us to arrive?

May Script

Well, yes, that's the idea!
You sure catch on quick!

Final Script

Well, ah, yes.
You catch on quick!

100 meseta!

What?

May Script

I'll take you with me
for 100 meseta.
I hope you weren't thinking of
asking me to go for nothing?

Final Script

We'll take you with us
for 100 meseta.
I hope you weren't thinking of
asking to tag along with us
for free?

May Script

Er...I can't get any money
even from the principal...

Final Script

Er...I can't get that kind of
money from the principal...

Translation Notes
The later English line is more accurate here.

May Script

They are completely different
stories altogether!

Now, what are you going to do?

Final Script

That's not my problem.
Now, what are you going to do?

Translation Notes
The May line should be "That's a different story altogether!". Not sure why they pluralized it.

...OK, I'll pay...

The three head into the basement and find it swarming with bio-monsters. On the lowest level, they discover containers that seem to be incubating the same monsters they've been fighting. They also encounter a larger green creature called the Igglanova that's spawning even more bio-monsters, but it's no big threat and they deal with it quickly.

We did it!

May Script

Chaz! You're not at your best.
Your swing is slow!

Final Script

Chaz! You need more practice.
Your swing is too slow!

Translation Notes
Alys's original second line mentioned Chaz's "fumikomi" being half-hearted. Fumikomi is a kendo technique that involves jumping forward to reach an opponent in a single step...it's harder than it sounds. Not hard to see what that line was rewritten, though.

May Script

What? But this thing now,
I have to admit, is hard to
...

Final Script

What? But we destroyed the
monster
...

Translation Notes
Chaz has a different objection in the final script...

May Script

Don't be sassy!!

Final Script

With my help...

Translation Notes
...and Alys is more stern in the May script.

Sorry.

Now, Hahn?
Come over here.

What?

May Script

What is this big glass bottle?
Come on, tell all!!

Final Script

What are these glass containers
for
?

Translation Notes
There's more than one glass container down in the basement.

May Script

Uh...It's...

Final Script

These...

May Script

Hey, are you by any chance
breeding monsters here?
If that's the case,
this monster business is
no 'mystery' after all!

Final Script

Hey, are you by any chance
breeding monsters here?
If that's the case,
this monster business is
no mystery after all!

May Script

I...I don't know anything!
It's the first time I've been
in a room like this!
I've only just learned that such
a thing exists at the academy!

Final Script

I...I don't know anything!
It's the first time I've been
in this room!
I've only just learned that such
a thing exists at the academy!

Umm....

May Script

R...really, it's the truth!

Final Script

Really, it's the truth!

May Script

It seems like you're not
necessarily lying.

Final Script

I believe you...for now.

Translation Notes
Alys isn't as easily convinced in the later drafts.

May Script

The principal should know!
He
must know what's in
this capsule
!

Final Script

The principal must know
about these containers!

Translation Notes
What's in the capsule is already established by this point.

May Script

Also, he must know what the
connection is between this
and the disappearance of
Professor Holt.

Final Script

He must also know the
connection between this
and the disappearance of
Professor Holt.

May Script

Hmm...that's splendid!
I'm off!
Chaz!

Final Script

Yes, let's see the principal
again. C'mon
Chaz!

May Script

Hey! Wait for me!
Don't leave me here!

Final Script

Hey!
Don't leave me here!

Back in the principal's office...

May Script

Wh...what's going on?
You seem upset.
Were you able to
defeat those monsters?

Final Script

Wh...what's wrong?
You seem upset.
Were you able to
defeat those monsters?

Translation Notes
Now that it's obvious that the Principal is guilty, the final script is fine with letting him start stammering again.

Yes, but there is something
I want to ask you.

What?

Is it just my imagination that
I saw some strange things
in the basement?

Ah...

May Script

Hey, you're hiding something,
aren't you!?

Somebody hiding something from
me is the sixth most hateful
thing in this world!

Final Script

Stop beating around the bush.

Someone keeping information
from me is the sixth most
dangerous thing in this world!

Translation Notes
The May line is accurate to the Japanese script (隠し事をされんのは あたしゃ世の中で6番目にキライなんだよ!), though it probably could have been phrased better. "My sixth most hated thing in this world", perhaps?

May Script

You're putting me in a bind!
All right already...
I'll tell all...
You are aware that recently,
there is an
outbreak of
a new breed of monsters?

Final Script

All right already...

I'll tell you what I know.
You are aware of the recent
outbreak of a new breed of
monster?

Translation Notes
The Principal is being literal in the May draft: Alys has the man bound by his shirt (See above picture.)

Oh yes. Thanks to the outbreak
I'm not hurting for work.

May Script

Holt identified Birth Valley as
the origin of the outbreak,
and it was three months ago
that
he went to investigate...
He says he discovered the
remains of an ancient and
advanced civilization!
The investigation team brought
back the monster breeding
capsules, and immediately set
forth on their second
investigative mission.
But...

Final Script

Three months ago, Holt
identified Birth Valley as
the origin of the outbreak,
and he went to investigate...
He says he discovered the
remains of an ancient and
advanced civilization!
The investigation team brought
back the monster breeding
capsules, and immediately set
forth on their second
investigative mission.
But...

Not one of them came back...

May Script

That's exactly right, Hahn.

Final Script

Yes, that's right Hahn.

And despite all this,
you didn't send out a rescue
team and banned entry to
Birth Valley!

No, no!
I...I was trying to send out
a rescue team! But...

Something happened?

At that moment
a man who called himself 'Zio'
appeared before my eyes...

Zio! I've heard of him.
That fake magician!

Ah, my dear principal of
Motavia Academy,
how are you doing?

May Script

Who was that!
Who are you!?

Final Script

Who... Who are you!?

My name is Zio...
Zio the black magician.
Do not intrude on Birth Valley.

What do you mean!?

In the future,
if you ever let anyone set foot
in Birth Valley...

May Script

Aargh!

Final Script

Ahhh!

Translation Notes
The May line makes it seem like he's more angry than scared.

Let me make something clear...
There is no need for you
to go to Birth Valley!

It's related to the research
team!

May Script

So that's why the Birth Valley
situation wasn't announced,
and also why you tried to keep
a lid on the monster situation.
But...what is all this?
Remains of an ancient advanced
civilization and Zio?

Final Script

So that's why the Birth Valley
situation wasn't announced,
and also why you tried to keep
a lid on the monster situation.
But...what is all this about?
Remains of an ancient advanced
civilization and Zio?

It seems like these are signs of
something to come.

May Script

That darn professor!
I'm going to Birth Valley!

Final Script

I need to help the professor!
I'm going to Birth Valley!

Translation Notes
Hahn's anger at the professor (or possibly of the situation he knows he's getting himself into) was rewritten. Seems more heroic in the later English drafts.

May Script

Hmmm.
This is egg-laying season for
sand worms, so be careful.
Also beware of the wild beasts
in that area.

Final Script

Psst. Hahn.
This is egg-laying season for
sand worms, so be careful.


Translation Notes
Alys originally warned Hahn about thieves, not wild beasts. Might have been changed because there aren't any actual thieves in the area, though the point is moot since the line was deleted from later drafts.

May Script

Er...Alys?

Final Script

Ah...Alys?

May Script

I'm not giving you one meseta
more than
300 plus expenses.

Final Script

We'll tag along for 300 meseta
plus expenses.

Translation Notes
A complete screw-up in the May draft: Hahn is supposed to be paying Alys, not vice versa.

May Script

Well?
Birth Valley is to the
northeast!
Let's hurry! ...sniff

Final Script

Ah...deal!
Birth Valley is to the
northeast!
Let's hurry!

Translation Notes
Hahn doesn't sniffle in later English drafts. Another attempt to de-weeniefy the guy, maybe.